By Julia Penhaligon
Cornwall’s countryside is about to come under a ferocious assault from property developers and County Hall planners, following publication of the latest government rules in pursuit of its ambition to build 1.5 million new houses before the next general election.
Cornwall has been given a mandatory target of around 4,500 new homes per year, a massive increase on previous years. Cornwall’s previous target was around 2,625 with planners and developers failing to meet even this, achieving only 1,700 completions last year.
The document is entirely silent on the contentious question of second homes, relying instead on conventional "supply-side" economic theory assuming that if you build enough houses, prices will fall to the point where they become affordable.
But many people say the market distortions caused by the demand for second homes are a huge part of Cornwall’s problems. The politics of someone owning more than one home while someone else has no home are easy to understand. The Labour government appears to have shied away from grasping this nettle.
Labour's planning rules also maintain the previous Conservative government's definition of "affordable" as meaning only a 20% discount on the open market price. In Cornwall, for many local people, this is unaffordable. Progressives lament Labour's reluctance to link its "affordable" definition to local incomes.
Cornwall currently has no Green or Grey belts, only urban areas, including rural villages, and open countryside. Hundreds – possibly thousands – of new homes will have to be built on the outskirts of rural villages if Cornwall is to meet the government’s mandatory target.
Although County Hall has identified more than 100 “brownfield” sites, sufficient to build 2,500 homes, much of the new development will be on agricultural land. Farmers and other land owners are rubbing their hands in glee at the prospect of dramatic profits as a result of new planning permissions.
At the same time Cornwall is experiencing a surge in second home ownership, despite the imminent 100% increase in council tax. There are now more than 14,000 second homes in Cornwall, a rise of 7.5% on last year, suggesting that the council tax hike needs to be far more aggressive if it is to have any deterrent effect.
Among the measures outlined this morning (Thursday) is a requirement on councils to plan for six years, rather than five, and a warning that any which fail to meet their targets risk losing control to Whitehall.
Cornwall currently has more than 26,000 approved planning applications where developers have simply "banked" the land and watched its value increase.




The government wants Cornwall to complete 87 new homes per week - delivering a massive boost to landowners and property developers, but alarming conservation groups
Related Posts
- Covid-19: Cornwall sees more new cases and clusters
Cornwall's latest Covid data reports 153.9 cases per 100,000 population, compared with 153 yesterday (Tuesday.) …
- New analysis reveals true cost of second homes
By Noah Law One of the announcements from Shadow Housing Secretary Matthew Pennycook MP this…
- Cornwall Council urged to make both second homes and holiday lets require a "change of use" planning consent
28th November 2018 By Rashleigh MacFarlane Local communities in Cornwall should be able to insist…
- Cornwall Council's new cabinet named
By Julia Penhalgion Linda Taylor, Leader David Harris, Deputy Leader Andy Virr, Adults Martyn Alvey,…
Hang on! The new target is 4,500 new homes per year for Cornwall – a home might be a unit in a block of flats or a detached house.
Cornwall currently has 26,000 approved but not started approved planning applications. Even if every planning application is only for a single home that would be nearly 6 years of target reached.
There is no need for any new planning applications to be approved. The council should be able to force existing plans to be implemented first. That is the way to drive down land prices – if you get planning permission and don’t complete the build within, say 3 years, the land is simply confiscated and goes into public ownership for resale to the highest bidder who can complete.
So a moratorium on all new planning approvals for new sites (perhaps allow knock-down and rebuild end-of-life houses) amd legal powers to take over land with unacted permission.
I totally agree. As well as this, as a planning policy, this is a totally anti-community approach and not in any way what local residents would wish for, as a way to foster a better community spirit. It also totally fails to address the ever increasing second home ownership in the county of Cornwallell as this,
In (supposedly) trying to deliver affordable housing, the notion of expecting prices to fall as demand and supply start to balance out will not be what the developers and land owners involved will want to go along with while continuing to rake in their fortunes from land and residential property sales.
The assumption in the planning rules, that the definition of ’affordability’ is a 20% discount on open market price leaves local buyers in Cornwall unable to afford the new properties, based on local income levels. This leaves the door wide open for second home ownership and holiday letting businesses to continue to hoover up more residential properties for their own uses. For these reasons, such an attempt at dealing with the current excessive housing price crisis will not have the desired effect. It will just ruin the residential housing environment for good.
The only viable alternative policy would be that set out on my web site which can be found if you search for’The House Price Solution’.